Circuit Wire — a daily news update from the Circuit.
Britain's Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday, November 19, that the UK government can no longer refuse to confirm it served Apple with a secret order aimed at the encryption on iCloud accounts. In an open judgment, the three judges stated that the government "has given Apple a technical capability notice," The Record reports, ending official silence on an order first reported in February 2025.
The notice was issued under section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. It targeted Advanced Data Protection, an opt-in iCloud setting that generates and stores encryption keys on users' own devices. Apple withdrew the feature for British users rather than comply, and the original demand reportedly covered customer data anywhere in the world, TechCrunch reported. The order was later narrowed to British nationals' data, and Apple is challenging that version too.
The government had argued that even confirming or denying the notice would damage national security. The tribunal disagreed, finding that confirmation would tell adversaries nothing they could not already find elsewhere. It pointed to British media reports citing government officials and to public comments by US politicians. According to Privacy International, the judges also found that the government had weakened its own neither-confirm-nor-deny policy by acknowledging the notice to reporters and to the US government.
The case was brought by Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals before Lady Carmichael, Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson. It is being managed alongside Apple's own challenge, filed in July 2026. The ruling makes no finding on whether the notice is lawful, and a substantive hearing is scheduled for the first half of 2027.
After the judgment, a government spokesperson said the notice only requires Apple to keep the ability to provide lawful access, and that terrorists, child abusers and organized crime groups cannot be allowed to operate beyond the reach of the law. Apple said it welcomed the decision to make the notice public.
The order has drawn criticism in Washington since it surfaced. Tulsi Gabbard, then US Director of National Intelligence, ordered a legal review of the directive in February 2025, and White House officials and members of Congress have said it would put Americans' privacy at risk.
Want a weekly roundup of the major stories shaping the security industry? The On The Circuit newsletter is read by more than 12,000 protection professionals.
Spotted something we should cover? Send tips and feedback via circuit-magazine.com.

